The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

On Bonding, holism and trust

Malta Independent Wednesday, 1 December 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

When listening to the radio programme ‘Newsdesk’ on Radio 101, travelling to my clinic I happened to hear PN parliamentarian Peter Micallef, a former class mate from university years

He spoke of the government’s trying to reform primary care in order to gain the trust of people and re-establish the ‘bonding’ between doctor and patient, and to restore a holistic approach to primary care.

While nothing can be further from the truth, one must add that these traits remain on the island. Only they remain in the form of the private family doctor. Family doctors in Malta can only be found in the private sector. They are numerous, strategically placed and very, very affordable. Those who wish to avail themselves of a free service can make use of excellent doctors at health centres, but cannot establish an ongoing relationship with one doctor and thus form a ‘bonding’ of the type Dr Micallef was talking about. I am not in a position to assume that health centres do not provide a ‘holistic’ approach.

Dr Micallef has worked in the health centres and knows more than I do. However it stands to reason that what he says is true since a holistic approach cannot be obtained with one visit to the doctor and needs an on-going relationship and this bonding, in order to establish the trust necessitated in this fiduciary relationship so that a holistic approach can be reasonably reached.

Health centres were established by a Labour government in different times. At the time they may have been an improvement of what the government offered at the time – the District Medical Officer. Most practice however was privately based and GPs were used to working during the day and during the night, with little in-between rest. It is not probable that we would wish to go back to those days. The world has changed even for medicine. As much as health centres removed workload (and hence income) from the private sector, it also afforded a certain amount of relief to the working doctor. Moreover patients have become used to availing themselves of both government and private services. Thus many private family doctors need not worry too much if they do not find a locum (someone to stand in for them) when they are abroad. The system has it covered, as it were.

Nevetheless there are also those who would only make use of health centres, and although a vox pop showed most of the people to be happy, they may not be in a position to know what the other system has to offer. Neither can everyone be sufficiently competent to know what public health officials know – and therefore what is good for one’s health. Thus someone may be quite content to have a walk-in service for his or her needs, but a holistic approach would require much more. I may therefore be happy with my standard Sedan car, but not know what a BMW has to offer.

It is certain therefore, that no matter how good the doctors working in health centres are, they are limited in what they have to offer by the specifications of the health centre itself. They cannot provide, even though they are competent to do so, an on-going private relationship of the tyor which produces ‘trust’, ‘bonding’, and ‘holism’, that Dr Micallef was speaking about. The latter diplomatically did not distinguish between the private sector and health centres – at least not within the bracket of time I was listening – the time it takes to drive from home to the clinic; so I apologise if I missed this.

But the distinction nevertheless must be made. The private family doctors do indeed provide these three characteristics, which is why the Health Minister had attempted to make use of them in recognition of the important role family doctors have to play in our system, which the health centres cannot fill in.

Admonishing patients not to abuse the system is not enough and going to ‘your’ doctor for an admission ticket is not on the offing at health centres. People are said to “abuse the system” – in reality they are doing what they feel they can do. No one feel he or she may be abusing the system. MAM has been adamant to reassure the public that the system overload is not the fault of GPs. Indeed it cannot be, even if they make a lot of referrals. GPs can offer only so much. Not all referrals need be actual admissions to hospital in order to be justified. Sometimes immediate tests to exclude conditions and/or a period of observation are necessary. Certainly if one had one’s own doctor the number may go a little down. Not that it will solve any major problems.

The proposal was temporarily shelved because rightly so, doctors felt that they had to be involved at drawing board level and not merely at giving feedback to a document. The latter by default puts the designer on the defensive. This should not be the case: an architect who proposes a plan without due consultation to the needs of the clients will only charge his clients for work which they have rejected. Even if they accept the plan, they later find that their wish-list may not have been satisfied. The good designer will of course only start once he knows what the clients want and what he is willing to pay for. Be the client the Minister, or the medical profession, who have to buy the plan, this is always the case. One augurs that these wishes come through. It is not only about registration. Registration comes as a consequence of a good proposal.

  • don't miss