For years we have been living with the deep-rooted belief, propagated by the Chicago school, that markets will regulate themselves – the now discredited theory of the invisible hand. This dogma was so strong in the West that we threw the book of rules out of the window and gifted the market with complete freedom. Today’s taxpayers are paying the bill for the blind faith of their leaders in economic theories based on academia not practice and definitely not on the workings of human nature. This is why nobody really knows what to do; we have seemingly run out of theories and this is demonstrated by the dozens of conflicting theories on sale. The cacophony and inconsistencies between governments, which on the one hand have allowed financial markets to dictate their policies and on the other side refuse to show European solidarity, is undermining the foundations of the European Union. First the Greek crisis and now Ireland have shown that agreement is easier to achieve during fair weather. In stormy seas, ships tend to give themselves as much sea room as possible.
Malta has struggled hard to formulate an EU immigration policy, even if it only did so after those of us who, alarmed by the large number of boat people arriving on our shores, sounded the tocsin. Let us forget that initially we were called all the names in the book: the reality finally moved the hearts and minds of our politicians. But they too soon learnt how difficult voluntary co-operation is. And so it has remained. Each time a crisis hits the EU, the first thought of its leaders is how best to protect their own people, which of course is the duty of every government.
Is there a way out of the present really serious impasse? There are those who argue that crises cannot be solved by individual governments and hence we need to accelerate the formation of a European government. There are also those who are again beginning to silently contemplate that the future might well mean a return to the past; a commercial, industrial and financial union solving problems peacefully round a European table. Once financial security is achieved, there would be little scope for a return to the destructive tensions of the past.
I have never believed that the nation state had reached its terminal gasp. It still retains a great deal of influence because it is the prime source of political legitimacy and of legal and military authority. The dream that millions of Europeans could forget their heritage and invest in a federal government was always going to be difficult to turn into reality, if for no other reason than that the times now dictate that our rulers consult civil society, which is increasingly forming part of the political equation. In the case of the EU, the distance between the rulers and the ruled does not make the heart grow fonder.
Nor has the behaviour of the elites in Brussels helped to instil confidence in that institution. The way they treat the EU, as if it were their personal pot of gold, is enough to make citizens all over Europe think at least twice before handing over complete power to politicians beyond the reach of accountability. And European citizens have been doing precisely that, as the numbers participating in European elections continue to decline. At which point does the legitimacy of the process come into question?
There is of course another problem and that is one of sovereignty. For a nation this means that its elected leaders have the duty to take all decisions in the interest of the people they represent. This interest is defined by more than just need: it is prescribed by the parameters of geography, history, language and tradition. What is good for one group of people may be less good for another. Can one ever mix the German culture with that of the Greeks? Can the Nordic work ethic ever come to terms with the Levantine ways of doing things that prevails in southern Europe? No less a person than Joschka Fischer criticises Germany for its present insulation and for seemingly switching from the desire to create a “European Germany” to one of a “German Europe”, which not only will not work but will bring back all the old fears, all the old animosities.
But is the concept of sovereignty still relevant? There are those that claim it is not. Many point out that it is the market that is now sovereign and that even the biggest of states find it extremely difficult not to bow their heads to its behests. Naturally, the smaller the state the weaker its power to fend off the demands not only of it own financial players but even more those of the dominant global ones. As the State shrinks under the impact of the globalised financial blitzkrieg, so too does its power to protect its citizens from the effects of unfettered and unregulated markets.
Markets of course have their distinctive qualities – chief among them their fluidity, their capacity to respond to a multitude of pricing signals and to stimulate innovation thus giving consumers choices. They also contribute to rapid growth that makes people more prosperous. But if we are to prevent a state of affairs where the rich become richer and the poor relatively poorer – and great imbalances imperil the social cohesion of any country − then the market needs to fall under sufficient political control. Otherwise democracy will be the loser as decisions start being made solely in the interest of those who own power and capital.
There has to be an effective and dynamic balance between the state, the marketplace and the civic order. Each acts as a check on the other and also provides a stimulus and challenge to them. Civil society will not flourish if the state ends up pared back to such an extent that it becomes a helpless player existing only for itself.
We live in a time when the communication revolution has given people not only easy and constant updates on any situation, but with it the power for each social group to react to the incoming information. As Anthony Giddens states, this fundamentally alters the nature of politics and government, as political support becomes more de-aligned than in the past and levels of party membership start to plummet. Attitudes of deference to authority figures and established institutions, including politicians and parliaments, decline. At the same time, disillusionment with politicians and the orthodox parliamentary process can produce periods of widespread apathy. Again this is not good news for the democratic process.
It is quite clear that the EU and most states in fact are adrift and do not know what course to take. The emergency is far from over despite what we continue to hear. In fact it is going into even more dangerous waters as Portugal, Italy and Belgium queue up, begging to be bailed out. This is no time for political strategies aimed solely at retaining or acquiring power. The danger is too great. We need a different breed of politician.
As Joschka Fischer pointed out, Europe has no shortage of politicians. What it urgently requires now are genuine statesmen and stateswomen with the courage to say it as it is and take the remedial action that is necessary without counting electoral gains or losses.