The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

No Better pay before better times

Malta Independent Tuesday, 14 December 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

If one had to ask me whether I consider the MPs honoraria to be decent or adequate I would in all honesty say no. Particularly for those who are engaged in a number of parliamentary committees. But this should in no way justify the poor timing, the insensitivity and nature of the hefty backdated increase that government introduced by stealth last week. Particularly given the dire straits many people happen to be in as I can confirm day in day out during my daily contact with constituents of all types of political orientation.

As an editorialist recently commented – there are two specific reasons for the public anger: the manner in which the move has been made known and naturally its timing.

The editorialist went on stating that: “What the people found particularly galling is the remarkable insensitivity the government has shown.”

Were it not for a PQ of mine that had focused solely on the reported increases in ministerial and parliamentary secretary salaries and allowances, this information would not have even seen the light of day. But then why did it have to take a PQ to trigger such public domain information?

I share the view that regardless of how the debate will develop, and while respecting all of my colleagues’ right to decide as they might deem fit, what is not open to debate is the extent of the rise for all MPs in the prevailing circumstances.

Former Nationalist Minister Louis Deguara was honest indeed when he told The Times last Saturday that although he did not yet know what he will do, he did not feel that it is the right moment for such an increase.

Last week I came across two contributions in the independent media by two former HSBC – Mid Med Bank colleagues of mine who were never known as PL membership card carrying members but who always struck me for their serious minded pursuit of just and equitable solutions and proposals. Regardless of whether one agrees in toto with their suggestions or not they indeed offer food for thought. In both instances, I have not crossed paths with them for quite some time.

One of them posted a blog – definitely without any prodding from my part – that the Opposition Leader should table a motion in Parliament that all MPs, ministers, parliamentary secretaries, chairmen of committees and all parliamentary political appointees should renounce to these increases until the economy of the country is in better shape and that any future increases will have to be debated in parliament and obtain a unanimous vote. Then – he added of his own free will – one can then see if the government members will vote in favour or against.

The other one called for People Power against the Cabinet salary rise, after having noted that many readers from all political hues were clearly dumbfounded by this Cabinet decision and have expressed genuine anger.

As he diligently pointed out:

“There is the general feeling that these increases are clearly unwarranted, especially at a time of unprecedented international economic crisis, which is by no means over. And there is this sense of helplessness in that the ordinary citizen can do nothing to change this.”

He disagreed and therefore proposed that a nationwide non-partisan petition should be raised to show that the ordinary citizen does have a voice in all this.

It is a fact that Malta might not have been hit as hard as Portugal, Spain, Ireland or Greece by the recession, mainly thanks to our prudent banks and an on the ball regulator, but such increases – including the 40% honoraria hike for all parliamentarians, jars at a point in time, when countries elsewhere have not only held back from introducing such increases. But they have actually downsized the pay packets of their cabinet members and parliamentarians as well as those of the chieftains of their government agencies and authorities.

After all Britain might not have a Red government in place, and yet one of the first measures that Mr Cameron introduced was a 5% cut in ministerial salaries together with a freeze on such salaries for the rest of the legislature – no matter how long it might last.

The Czechs have just done the same introducing a similar cut that should last for a minimum till 2014.

Through its insensitivity our government has proved itself once again to be totally out of sync with the times, insensitive to public concerns and as indifferent as it has proved to be over the past months and years to another major area of concern – that of environmental health.

While everyone is entitled to reach his own decision, I admire Joseph Muscat for having acted promptly without any hesitation in turning down his pay rise. Showing indeed that this is a moment of truth.

On my part, I feel comforted by the fact that although in these difficult times one would relish the opportunity of having more money in hand – if anything to cope with the hefty utility bills – my conscience is at rest that I took my decision within two minutes of deep reflection.

Particularly after realising that were it not for my PQ, I would have first come to realise of the pay rise and the extent of it when/if I would have first received my first upwardly revised salary slip.

[email protected]

www.leobrincat.com

Leo Brincat is the Shadow Minister for the Environment, Sustainable Development & Climate Change

  • don't miss