The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Public Accounts scrutiny

Malta Independent Sunday, 19 December 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

Parliamentary democracy is based on very simple notions: A legislature is elected by the people in free elections; the president or monarch appoints the person able to command a majority in Parliament as prime minister. In turn, the prime minister chooses the cabinet, the executive, answerable in the last resort to the people in elections, and to Parliament in the intermediate period between elections.

Members of Parliament are representatives of the people. Unconditioned and unconditional loyalty to their party does not impede or preclude them from voicing the concerns of their constituents, or the fundamentals of democracy, both within the internal party structures as well as in other fora such as Parliament itself, civil society and the media, depending on the issue.

When the Delimara power station extension was debated in Parliament last May, I criticised certain aspects of the procedure in line with the Auditor General’s findings. The Auditor General is an officer of the House, and he commands the respect of all.

I participated in the debate, and took the opportunity to make a number of environmental recommendations, including accelerating the infrastructure for gas and opting for the cleanest fuel. People living not only in Marsaxlokk or Żurrieq but also in Żejtun and Marsascala are directly affected by the power station: it is an issue that concerns the south of the island and beyond.

People in the area also complain of the inconvenience caused by the heavy industrialisation, whilst obviously appreciating and understanding their economic relevance to the country.

That debate gave Parliament the opportunity to scrutinise the government, a main function of a healthy legislature, controlling and overseeing the administration, besides enacting laws and being the highest and most representative forum of discussion. The debate came at a time when the process, started even before I was elected to Parliament, was in its final stages, and thus one had to calibrate various factors, including not only environmental issues, but also the issue of energy security, and commitments regarding the decommissioning of the Marsa power station.

Government has expressed its firm commitment to remedy the identified administrative shortcomings; no corruption or trading in influence was found.

Once again it must be stressed that the area needs a heavy injection of environmental projects and a further upgrading of the infrastructure to compensate for the deficit caused by progressive industrialisation.

I had the opportunity to be present at the opening of the upgraded Sant’ Antnin recycling plant, which is a huge improvement on the earlier plant whilst respecting and enhancing the environment. The interconnector with Sicily and the switch to alternative energy sources are good steps in the right direction.

The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) is another mechanism by which Parliament scrutinises the executive. It is not geared to criminal investigations – God-forbid that it were. In normal cases, even where the committee finds shortcomings, these are usually of an administrative nature. Otherwise, in exceptional situations, the Commissioner of Police would intervene with further investigations.

From the start, I voiced my opinion that the discussion should be held, and that witnesses should be allowed to testify before the PAC in the power station extension contract issue in the best interests of transparency and accountability and to clarify any remaining pending issues. But I also stressed that this was to take place only after the Auditor General has finished his testimony.

Business before the PAC must be conducted in a manner befitting the dignity of Parliament, and keeping in mind the role of the committee itself, namely the scrutiny of Government expenditure. As the Prime Minister has said, Parliament and the Public Accounts Committee should not be morphed into a police corps or a people’s tribunal.

Respecting the dignity of Parliament also means conducting the coming debate in the correct manner and in full respect of our Constitutional provisions.

Dr Debono is a Nationalist Member of Parliament

www.francodebono.info

  • don't miss