It is in the news again. Pensions have stolen the Christmas limelight, the social partners are up in arms and are discussing the latest recommendation for a mandatory second pillar. A study group is proposing that a second pension requirement should be introduced for those who are 45 and under. The unions do not relish more austerity measures, saying that their members have borne the brunt of the increased energy prices in recent years and do not have spare cash to save for the extra pillar.
One could ask why the study group failed to suggest the introduction of SIPP (self-invested personal pension) schemes in Malta. Typically, if a worker wishes to have a more flexible pension, he or she can opt to transfer his or her pension to a SIPP and still receive full tax relief. Naturally, such a move will be taken after consulting an MFSA-approved independent financial adviser. A SIPP is basically an investment plan that allows a person to save for retirement in a tax-efficient manner and can be a fantastic way of helping to achieve a more comfortable lifestyle after retirement. Approved SIPPs can invest in a wider range of funds and investments, including stocks and shares, unit trusts, Sicav’s insurance company funds and commercial property. SIPPs have become extremely popular investment plans in the UK, as they offer a greater diversity of investment. They give the option of making personal investment choices, although there is always the need to consult an adviser. In the UK, SIPPs – which have been in fashion for over 15 years – attract full tax relief (in Malta it should reach 35 per cent) while higher taxpayers can receive an additional 18 per cent tax relief. Additionally, there should be full exemption for Capital Gains Tax in a SIPP pension, and there are unlikely to be any inheritance tax issues. The investment product usually offers a variety of investment options, including property.
Investors can potentially receive sizeable tax breaks on any property they purchase and, unlike regular contributions under the standard PAYE scheme currently mandatory under the first pillar, will be able to borrow (eg obtain a mortgage) against the assets of SIPPS in order to leverage buying power and thus achieve a superior return on investment. This financial product will, in turn, help revive the sluggish domestic real estate market with over 50,000 vacant premises in need of better use. A well-designed SIPP option will also revive Malta’s fledging Stock Exchange, as it offers more opportunities for investment. Although to date SIPPs have not been on offer, we rejoice in the possibility of them being introduced here now that it appears that the second pillar will become a compulsory part of pensions. This is why PKF hosted a seminar entitled EU – Urging a Pension Reform in July to rekindle interest in such a delicate issue. It is true that the political class did not shed many tears on the subject, but then they reminded us that the Pension Study Group (chaired by David Spiteri Gingell) had been instructed to issue its final report this year. However, the seminar proved its worth as it brought the main stakeholders together to discuss and analyse the current situation, to objectively assess pension reform and to examine the options open to the government, unions and the private sector alike. Neither the Minister responsible for social policy nor the Prime Minister could attend, due to Cabinet business, so the seminar was opened by the Ministry’s parliamentary assistant Stephen Spiteri.
During the seminar Mr Spiteri Gingell, chairman of the Pensions Working Group between 2004 and 2007, described the changes in demographics, which will pervasively impact on a PAYG (pas as you go) pensions system. He pointed out that Malta’s population is falling because the birth rate is declining. According to his presentation, based on EU figures, the birth rate has declined from 3.5 per woman in 1960 to 1.5 in 2008. In contrast, life expectancy had risen to 80 by 2008. In 2050, 33 per cent of females and 31 per cent of males will be aged over 60. The AWG total population scenario, which results from assumptions pertaining to birth rates, life expectancy and net immigration, shows a decline to 405,000 in 2060. The dependency ratio will fall from 1:4 in 2005 to 1:15 by 2050. According to Mr Spiteri Gingell, Malta needs to start considering the following options: a higher birth rate; more female participation in the workforce; immigration; an increase in the retirement age; linking the retirement age with a longevity index and mitigating the demographic risk by complementing the PAYG with a second pillar.
Another speaker, Dr Gordon Cordina, was more optimistic and argued that a higher life expectancy, and an increase in the number of women who want to pursue a career, should not be seen as something negative. According to Dr Cordina, the system has not become any more or less affordable, but the risks have increased. At this point in time, he said, the emphasis should be on increasing the resilience of the PAYG pension scheme to risks and he suggested that, in order to achieve this, the retirement age should be linked to life expectancy, and increases in pension rates should be commensurate with increases in contributions, provided that there is no reduction in the purchasing poser of pensions.
Altering contribution rates, with a possible significant rise in the share of pension expenditure in the economy, is ultimately counterproductive to economic growth and the sustainability of the PAYG system itself.
All in all, Dr Cordina took the view that the present system should remain but needed to be constantly sustained through economic growth and a larger workforce. However, he also pointed out that a funded pension system may improve the situation, because a funded system is long-term as it is based on the capital market.
His presentation was echoed by MLP spokesman for finance and economic affairs Charles Mangion, who claimed that no substantive changes had been introduced except for the determining of the minimum pension to 60 per cent of median income, which incidentally is the threshold indicating the risk of poverty. During the euro debt crisis the government decided that it would not be wise to introduce a second pillar to pension provision, as this would directly increase costs and hamper national competitiveness. But Dr Mangion stressed that there is an urgent need for a comprehensive reform of the pension system to improve its sustainability and adequacy, and this can be postponed no longer.
The seminar was a follow-up to one held in 2003, at which Dr Lawrence Gonzi (then Social Policy Minister) was a speaker. Now, six days before Christmas, the ghost of pension’s future is haunting us for a way out. There have been a number of attempts by other EU countries to grapple with the pension problem and find a sustainable solution. PKF’s objective was to bring the main stakeholders together to discuss and analyse the situation at a time when the EU Commission was urging action. Paradoxically, now we read that, due to the acute debt crisis, certain countries have been forced to cut pensions. It is to be hoped that such austerity measures will be of a short duration and the countries concerned will recover and be able to rebuild the revenues that sustain pension funding. Back in Malta, under the law passed in 2006, the government is legally bound to carry out a five-yearly strategic review of the reform, so one hopes that changes will soon be introduced to reflect the current situation. It has now been recommended that a second pillar is essential and therefore has to be mandatory. So far, the unions are rejecting this recommendation, pointing out that the workforce is already over-stretched and cannot “save” more in 2011, given their meagre weekly €1.60 COLA increase.
To conclude, Santa certainly needs to fill up our Christmas stockings with more goodies to help us face the extra contributions next year. Let’s hope that this issue is not politicised to score cheap political points because it is too important an issue for petty bickering. Let’s also hope that our politicians, with their guaranteed pensions plus their bumper salary increase, are mature enough to deal with the issue.
A Merry Christmas to all.
George Mangion is a partner in PKFMALTA, an audit and business advisory firm.
[email protected]