The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Children And charity

Malta Independent Thursday, 23 December 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

This is not because it is the Catholic Church. It could well be any other religion for all I care, though the way the Catholic Church is treated as a valid extension of the state of Malta, taking on all responsibility, largely at its own expense and balanced precariously and unfairly on the unpaid round-the-clock labour of nuns and priests, is something I find intolerable. The contribution of religious orders to education and social services, like that of the private sector, should be complementary and ancillary to the main tranche of services provided by the state. This is how it is with schools and care homes for old people. That is how it used to be with health care, in the days when orders of nuns ran hospitals. But that is not how it is with the care of abandoned children.

It is just unbelievable that in the 21st century Malta has still not organised itself for the care of its abandoned children and those who are forcibly removed from their parents because of ill-treatment. The same situation prevails as did in the 19th, 18th, 17th, 16th, 15th centuries and way beyond, with children dumped on nuns and priests and charity. The only difference to those days is that the state now chucks a bit of money at the nuns and priests to help them along, but it still leaves everything up to them. The nature of this pitiable farce is best illustrated by the fact that the state has made legal and organisational provision for the removal of children from abusive parents, without also making provision for their care, which it doesn’t see as its responsibility. Instead, it sends them to the nuns and priests. A child sequestered from heroin addicts? Off to the nuns and priests. A refugee baby found floating in the sea? To the Ursuline Creche. A teenage boy removed from a father who beats him? To St Patrick’s.

And we accept this. We accept that the care of children abandoned by or removed from their parents should be 100% dependent on the Catholic Church. Because we belong to the Catholic Church and admire it, or simply because we are used to it having grown up in this culture, we are unable to separate out the argument that this is not its responsibility, that a developed welfare state should look after its weakest and most vulnerable. I find it horrendous that government after government has invested in the state-owned home for old people while completely blanking out the idea – oh, what a novel idea – of state-run care for children.

And yet again, neither the government party nor the Opposition party has thought this matter worth bothering about. They’re going to rely on nuns and priests until the nuns and priests run out. By then, we might be in the 22nd century. “This is not Ethiopia,” the Ursuline sisters told the press a couple of days ago, as they asked people to please not turn up on their doorstep with any more food because it would only go to waste. They have too much already.

No, Malta is not Ethiopia, but in this matter it is exactly the same. Malta, like Ethiopia, relies on the charity of Catholic nuns for the care of its abandoned children, thereby perpetuating the unwholesome belief among the Maltese that looking after those abandoned children is an act of charity by volunteers and nice, good religious people rather than the mandatory duty of the state.

If residential homes for children were run by the state, nobody would be turning up on their doorstep with crates of food, no more than we turn up at Mater Dei with a little something to bulk out the fare in the canteen. The assumption which underpins these food donations is that children at the Ursuline Creche must be going without because they are dependent on charity. That is what I find shocking: that instead of clamouring to have those children taken off charity and properly looked after by our taxes in purpose-built contemporary buildings with proper management, we give ourselves a golden glow by revisiting the era of Scrooge and Tiny Tim and turning up with a panettone and a box of fruit juice.

I fully approve of donations of new toys and even new clothes. They would be welcome even if the children are in state-run homes, even if the children are with their parents for that matter (but then they are called presents) because children should always be given things like that however well-cared-for they are. It makes them feel special, something they particularly need when they are brushed off by their parents and dumped with 30 others in a regimented environment. But food? For heaven’s sake – those who really did think that children in care homes were going without basic sustenance shouldn’t have rushed to the Ursuline Sisters with a rescue hamper. They should have asked themselves why, in 2010, abandoned children are still dependent on our food hampers rather than our taxes.

www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com

  • don't miss