The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Certifications And company doctors

Malta Independent Wednesday, 29 December 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

In response to a letter appearing on 17 December in reply to my article on the pitfalls of company doctors, I would refrain from responding word for word so as not to create unnecessary debate, as I feel that Jean Karl Soler, being an occupational physician himself (one deduces this from the content of the contribution) may have read too much into what I wrote

Whilst thanking him for the feedback, suffice to say that cases can legitimately be used for discussion if sufficient detail is removed so that identities cannot be revealed. In view of this the commentator is in no position to tell whether medical council was resorted to or not. Moreover he assumes that the case mentioned (on hypertension) does not fall into the 2.2% category which he admits can give rise to certification. But in commenting about the case example one misses the forest for the trees – the whole point being to discuss the pitfalls in local occupational medicine. Whilst no one made any derogatory comments on doctors working in this field, and indeed I did so myself for more than 15 years until my full-time appointment at university, I do not hesitate to repeat and make no apologies for asserting that doctors working without a collective agreement verge in a dangerous area of the law. It is probably illegal and definitely in breach of ethics to go to people’s homes solicited by an employer.

Even with a collective agreement, Dr Soler and I are in agreement that ‘reserving the right to send a doctor discriminates between workers’. He says that the system works and that the alternative does not work. I would say there are many other alternatives and that the very fact we debate here shows it is time that the profession focuses on this area and draws up a code of practice for doctors and guidelines for employers. Indeed the medical council is discussing aspects of the law on this. Reserving the right to send a doctor means that someone who is not a doctor himself or herself is deciding whether a person on sick leave needs a doctor or not. Clearly they do not have the professional capacity to do so. An innocent doctor, even with good intentions, would simply be falling prey to bad practice. I stand on no pedestal but I think that after almost 20 years of practice in both family medicine and occupational medicine, and specialising and working locally and at European level on clinical ethics and law, I may be in a position, without presumptuousness, to inform the public about their rights and perhaps share my experiences with other doctors so that hopefully they are not eaten for breakfast by a lawyer. I have been witness to a landmark case which I had brought forward to the attention of the management and which ended in court. It was about verbal abuse but the very nature of why management sent me was indeed to see why she went home and not because of any concern. When I defended the patient I knew what I was in for. I cannot say I am happy I lost that job a few weeks after the trial but if it is for that reason and because I got on their nerves – not giving in to pressure, for example, to visit the same person three times in a day because the manager was sure the worker was abusing – cannot but at least leave me cherishing some pride in my work. How can a manager, of a large company, resort to such techniques? How can he know whether a patient requires two or more visits in a day? Especially when there is a family doctor as well… Is this not policing? The problem is not with innocent doctors, who try perhaps to reconcile and give in to some pressure in doing so. The problem is with the employers who make us take these risks. Nevertheless it is us who commit the errors of our duties, I am afraid, and in doing so resort to disagreeing with other members of the profession just as competent as we are. We all agree there is abuse by many workers and perhaps some doctors who issue certificates liberally (I do not believe they do, for a doctor has to base his relationship on trust), but the policing can be left to some supervisor or doorman.

Otherwise we all agree that occupational medicine has an important role to play. How my article could have caused ‘hurt’ feelings is a mystery to me but I am sorry if it did.

On a different note I wish today to speak about the ordeals facing doctors when they order an autopsy. The law stipulates that doctors should have seen deceased patients at least two weeks before the time of passing away in order to issue a death certificate. Matters are better when someone dies in hospital. At home, one presumes that the doctor knows about the condition of the patient and that a death certificate can be issued. But sometimes tragedy hits families and young people die unexpectedly. Sometimes families insist that no autopsy is done and the doctor takes a big risk if he issues a certificate without a knowledge of the cause of death. At other times it seems that even the police expect that the doctor can reasonably issue a certificate if there are no signs of violence. But when the doctor feels that an autopsy should establish the cause of death and that the family have a right to know, especially if they are requesting to know why the person died, then it can take much more time in a situation which is already very difficult for the family.

When an autopsy is requested, the district police have to be called. These poor fellows must follow a procedure even if the doctor confirms and takes the responsibility that there seemed to be a natural cause (or a medical one) of death. An inquiry has to be made in which a magistrate is appointed, a police inspector is summoned, the forensic department come to take photos and the court medical experts come to confirm what the original doctor said. The police then take the body and the autopsy is done. If a person conversely dies in an ambulance all this is unnecessary.

Although I am not an expert about procedures in hospital, I imagine that a magistrate is still informed. In this sense therefore, if someone dies at home, the same scenario is taken as if one is suspecting foul play. This is reasonable. But what of those doctors who take the risk at times and still issue a certificate. Police usually appreciate this and it is not the first time I was asked whether an autopsy was really necessary. Since it seems that the law is being too stringent for natural deaths, perhaps it is time to avoid all the hassle and indeed the prolonging of the agony on the family who have just lost a loved one.

  • don't miss