The Malta Independent 18 May 2024, Saturday
View E-Paper

No Family Day here

Malta Independent Tuesday, 23 June 2015, 09:24 Last update: about 10 years ago

It was reported that as many as one million people took part in a demonstration in Rome last weekend for the so-called “Family Day”. The purpose of this event was for people to gather in name of the “traditional family” values and to stand against any legislation in favour of giving LGBT couples more rights.

Since Ireland introduced, through a popular referendum, legislation that allows two men and two women to marry, the talk on same-sex unions heated up in Italy once again. The Italian government had once again realised how the country is lagging behind on gay rights issues, especially when a strongly religious country like Ireland (only comparable to Italy in Europe for its adherence to Catholic morals) made such moves.

The main reason, in fact, why the Irish referendum triggered such reactions in Italy is the country’s famous attachment to the Catholic ethos, which has had for decades a strong influence on its culture and politics. However, regardless of its “conservativeness”, Ireland granted gay couple the right to marriage before Italy did.

Italy is one of the few EU countries left with no legislation on civil unions or marriage for LGBT couples. After the Irish referendum, prime minister Matteo Renzi pledged to introduce legislation on the matter by July.

Therefore, as the month comes closer and the Italian government is making its decisions on civil union laws, protesters gathered in central Rome to show their support for the traditional family values and the protection of children from “different” family structures. “Let us defend our children” was the slogan used by most protestors.

“Our main goal was to fill in Rome’s squares with thousands of families from all over the country to protect the innocence of our children and their right to have a mother and a father, and to re-state our strong opposition to any decision of changing our constitution” said Massimo Gandolfini, one of the event’s main organisers.

The last “Family Day” took place in 2007, and saw former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi as one of the many participants. In Sunday’s event, over one hundred Italian MPs took part, and minister Angelino Alfano tweeted how he will let the protesters’ voices be heard in the fight for defending their children from pro-gay marriage legislation.

Most members of the Italian Democratic Party, however, dismissed Sunday’s demonstration as a “bizarre protest against human rights”, stressing how the government has already decided to introduce legislation on same-sex unions in the near future and has no intention of making steps backwards on the matter of gay rights.

Seen from the perspective of Malta, all this looks rather ‘passe’’ since Malta has taken quite signal steps with regards to the LGBT issues and without conflicts such as the searing public discussion there was in Ireland and the equally searing public discussion that took place in France and now in Italy.

We have had a referendum on divorce and now a referendum on hunting but none, as in Ireland, subject to a referendum on civil unions and LGBT issues. The matter was settled in Parliament.

One remembers the crowd which gathered in Palace Square and the Opposition members coming out to jeers and catcalls. Since then, the Opposition has even reversed its position and is now as broadly pro-LGBT as the Government.

On the one hand, we may count ourselves lucky the historic step was taken in a civil manner but equally we may perhaps be allowed to regret that there was no wide and extensive public consultation such as has happened, is happening, in other countries.

The country is made up of different opinions and it is right that the majority must never be allowed to ride roughshod over the minority but then it is right too that shades of opinion be allowed free expression, as long as the proper rules of free expression are kept.

The country has now moved on, as it did after the introduction of divorce and has integrated the new changes as regards same-sex persons with minimal disturbance. There are multiple reasons for all this on all levels of society. But it would be bad for the social cohesion of the country if shortcuts are taken and proper discussion is short-circuited.

 

  • don't miss