The Malta Independent 25 July 2026, Saturday
View E-Paper

TMID Editorial: Protecting children requires more than policies

Thursday, 20 November 2025, 10:47 Last update: about 9 months ago

Malta's first Safeguarding Commission conference, convened by the Archdiocese last week, marked a notable moment: an institution historically shaken by abuse scandals publicly renewing its call for vigilance, reform, and responsibility. But if we're honest, the significance of this event reaches far beyond ecclesial walls. Protecting children from abuse - whether in the Church, at home, in schools, in sports, or online - demands something larger than institutional statements. It demands a nation willing to face uncomfortable truths and to act decisively.

The message from Archbishop Charles Scicluna and Bishop Luis Manuel Ali Herrera was clear: safeguarding is not optional, and it is not the job of any single organisation. Abuse thrives in silence, in cultural habits that discourage speaking up, in communities that still hesitate to believe victims, and in systems that favour reputation over responsibility. Breaking that pattern requires a cultural shift - one Malta must be willing to embrace fully.

One of the most striking themes from the conference was the emphasis on shared mission. Scicluna quoted a line from the film Spotlight: "It takes a village to educate a child - it also takes a village to protect a child." That is not only a moral lesson; it is a practical one. Many of the most damaging cases of abuse persist because too many adults assume someone else will notice, someone else will intervene, someone else will keep watch. Children cannot be expected to protect themselves from manipulation, coercion, or violence. That burden falls on us - the adults, the institutions, the communities that shape their world.

The Church's own acknowledgment that abuse has occurred within its ranks, including abuse with a devastating spiritual dimension, is an important step. But acknowledgment alone cannot heal wounds or prevent future harm. Safeguarding must be lived, not merely spoken. Training, transparent procedures, mandatory reporting, and independent oversight are not bureaucratic add-ons - they are moral imperatives. When the Archdiocese notes increasing requests for safeguarding training from NGOs and other organisations, it signals a broader awakening: people are willing to learn how to do better. That momentum needs nurturing, not applause.

Bishop Herrera's reminder that safeguarding is "simple yet challenging" captures the tension. The principles - kindness, dignity, protection - sound straightforward. But living them requires courage to confront abusers, determination to reform flawed systems, and humility to admit past failures. His reference to Malta's heritage, recalling the "unusual kindness" shown to shipwreck survivors in the biblical account of St Paul, is more than a historical nod. It's a call to rediscover a national ethic: that true hospitality includes protecting the vulnerable.

If Malta wants to lead by example, we must treat safeguarding as a national responsibility, not a Church responsibility, not an NGO responsibility, not a parental responsibility alone. Abuse is not confined to one institution, and neither should prevention be. Schools, youth clubs, sports associations, digital platforms, and social services all play a critical role. But so do neighbours. So do family members. So do bystanders who sense something is wrong but feel uncertain about acting.

Children's lives and dignity are worth the discomfort of difficult conversations. They are worth the administrative burden of thorough background checks. They are worth the insistence that any adult working with children - anywhere - undergo rigorous safeguarding training. And when a child speaks up, they deserve to be believed, protected, and supported without hesitation.

Protecting children requires more than hope; it requires vigilance. More than sympathy; it requires action. More than policies; it requires courage.

Malta can show "unusual kindness" again - not only by welcoming the vulnerable, but by defending them. That is the village our children deserve.


 

  • don't miss