The Malta Independent 24 July 2026, Friday
View E-Paper

TMIS Editorial: year of reckoning, and the questions 2026 will not allow us to avoid

Sunday, 28 December 2025, 09:00 Last update: about 8 months ago

As 2025 draws to a close, it leaves behind a sense of uneasy pause rather than resolution. It was a year in which several issues remained on top of the national agenda, most notably the environment, governance, and the sustainability of Malta's development model. Yet, while public pressure intensified and certain red lines were tested, few of the underlying structural problems were meaningfully addressed. The coming year will test whether the political class has absorbed the lessons of the past 12 months, or whether it will continue to manage dissent rather than respond to it.

The environment remained a top bone of contention throughout 2025, largely because of the government's proposed planning reforms. Framed as technical adjustments, these reforms were quickly perceived by many as a developers' wishlist, weakening safeguards and facilitating further intensification in an already overbuilt country. The reaction was swift and broad-based. Civil society groups, environmental NGOs and ordinary citizens voiced concern that the reforms would permanently tilt the balance away from public interest and towards private gain.

To the government's credit, it eventually recognised the scale of the backlash. Plans to rush the legislation through Parliament before the summer recess were shelved, and further discussion was promised. This pause, however limited, demonstrated that sustained public pressure can still have an impact. The protests that took place in October were not merely symbolic; they reflected a deeper frustration with decision-making processes that appear increasingly detached from public sentiment.

That willingness to listen, however, has not been consistently applied. The contrast with the handling of the magisterial reform inquiry is striking. In that case, the government opted to fast-track legislation through Parliament, effectively curbing citizens' ability to request magisterial investigations. The speed and manner in which the reform was pushed through left little room for meaningful debate and reinforced perceptions that consultation is welcomed only when it does not obstruct political priorities.

The government has meanwhile continued to present itself as environmentally conscious. Proposals to transform Fort Campbell, Manoel Island and White Rocks into national parks are positive and welcome. Such initiatives deserve recognition. Yet they cannot be viewed in isolation, nor can they compensate for years of planning decisions that have eroded open spaces and strained communities. Environmental credibility is built through consistency, not selective gestures.

This inconsistency was again highlighted by recent Planning Authority decisions. Approval for an additional 13 storeys on the already controversial Pembroke development epitomised the problem. Originally sanctioned at 17 and 18 storeys, the towers are now set to rise to 23 and 25 floors, before the first phase has even been completed. As Graffitti rightly observed, such decisions make a mockery of the planning process. The same applies to the decision to allow a 13-storey structure in Xlendi, and this after Prime Minister Robert Abela had insisted that Gozo should remain free of highrise buildings.

Beyond the environmental sphere, 2025 saw the continued neglect of over-population and its cascading effects. Traffic congestion, pressure on infrastructure and declining quality of life remain persistent features of daily life, yet no coherent strategy has emerged to address them. Short-term fixes continue to substitute for long-term planning, reinforcing a sense of drift rather than direction.

Economic warning signs were also increasingly difficult to ignore. The national debt continued its upward trajectory, nearing €11.5 billion. While the figures are often downplayed, the implications are serious. Debt accumulation may be politically convenient in the short term, but it inevitably constrains future choices. The absence of a clear plan to stabilise public finances raises questions about intergenerational responsibility.

The year also marked the end of the golden passports scheme, a programme that generated revenue but at significant reputational cost. Its closure was overdue and underscored the tension between financial expediency and ethical governance. Alongside this, Malta faced infringement proceedings related to bird trapping, and an arbitration decision concerning the hospitals deal, with cases related to it continuing to crawl through the courts with little visible progress. These issues, taken together, reinforced concerns about accountability and the rule of law.

Looking ahead, 2026 will be the last full year before the next general election, and political tension is set to rise accordingly. The Nationalist Party, after yet another leadership change in 2025, will seek to convince voters that it represents a credible alternative to a Labour government aiming for a fourth consecutive victory. Whether it can do so will depend less on rhetoric and more on its ability to articulate a coherent vision that addresses the structural challenges laid bare in recent years.

The coming year will not allow for complacency. Environmental limits, institutional trust, public finances and democratic safeguards are no longer abstract concerns. They are increasingly tangible, and increasingly urgent. The question is whether 2026 will mark the beginning of a genuine course correction, or simply another year in which difficult decisions are deferred.


  • don't miss